Published · Updated

US Deputy Defense Secretary Colby criticizes Ukrainian strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure at Ramstein meeting

At the opening of the 37th Ramstein Contact Group session at NATO headquarters in Brussels on 17 November 2026, US Deputy Secretary of Defense Elbridge Colby said Ukraine has for a second consecutive month liberated more territory than Russia has captured, and that Russian forces have suffered their heaviest monthly losses of the full-scale war. Colby judged Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure, including Wildberries warehouses, ineffective for ending the war and for slowing Russian advance, while stressing that US support should focus on holding the front line and that his warnings do not mean Ukraine should fight with its hands tied. Germany's Boris Pistorius and the UK's Wes Streeting publicly pushed back.

Key points

  • Colby spoke on 17 November 2026 at the opening of the 37th Ramstein Contact Group session at NATO headquarters in Brussels
  • Colby said Ukraine has for a second consecutive month liberated more territory than Russia captured
  • Russian forces suffered their heaviest monthly losses of the full-scale war, in October
  • Colby said Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure, including Wildberries sites, were ineffective for ending the war and slowing Russia's advance
  • He said such strikes likely hardened Russian public resolve and Kremlin readiness to escalate
  • Colby named the US priority as enabling Ukraine to hold the front line and advance where possible
  • Colby said continued PURL financing is needed, with primary responsibility falling on Europe
  • Ukrainian strikes on Wildberries warehouses across multiple Russian regions began in mid-July and later extended to Ozon
  • Ukrainian forces reportedly struck at least nine Russian refineries between 30 October and 11 November 2026, accounting for over 36% of Russia's refining capacity

Why it matters

A senior US defense official publicly questioning the effectiveness of strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure signals friction between Washington and Kyiv over how deep attacks into Russia are allowed to go. Colby set out the US support priority as holding the front line and advancing where possible, plus European burden-sharing through the PURL mechanism and European defence industry. German defence minister Boris Pistorius and UK defence minister Wes Streeting publicly pushed back on the criticism, showing allied disagreement at the Ramstein meeting. Ukraine has reportedly hit at least nine Russian oil refineries, accounting for about 36% of Russia's refining capacity, which Colby implicitly separated from strikes on civilian commercial infrastructure. Colby warned the conflict will be prolonged, with Russia continuing to mobilize manpower and the economy.

What happened

Elbridge Colby, US Deputy Secretary of Defense for policy, spoke on Tuesday 17 November at the opening of the 37th Ramstein Contact Group session at NATO headquarters in Brussels. He said Ukraine has for a second consecutive month liberated more territory than Russia captured, that Russian forces suffered their heaviest monthly losses of the war, and that focusing Ukrainian forces on holding the front with medium-range drone strikes to disrupt Russian logistics is the most effective way to defend Ukraine and create conditions for ending the war. At the same time he assessed Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure, including Wildberries warehouses, as ineffective for ending the war and slowing Russian advance, and said such strikes likely hardened Russian public resolve and Kremlin readiness to escalate. He allowed that the balance of advantage in long-range strikes could be entirely on Moscow's side, while stressing that his warnings do not mean Ukraine should be made to fight with its hands tied. On support, Colby said the US focus should be on Ukraine's ability to hold the front line and advance where possible, called for continued PURL financing with primary responsibility falling on Europe, urged European allies to rebuild their defence industry around military needs, and asked the US Congress to back President Trump's budget request for munitions, drones and other warfighting capabilities. He also said the US will continue facilitating high-technology arms purchases under JUMPSTART and welcomed the EU decision to fund American weapons, including a first purchase of Patriot interceptors.

How Ukrainian sources describe it

Ukrainian outlets foregrounded Colby's battlefield figures — Ukraine liberating more territory than Russia for a second month running and Russian forces suffering their heaviest monthly losses of the war — as evidence that the front is holding. Ukrainian reporting highlighted the military focus on holding the line with medium-range drone strikes on Russian logistics, and increasingly frequent strikes on ballistic missile launch and production sites as air defence stocks shrink. Ukrainian sources also carried the General Staff's justification that Ukraine acts within the right of self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter while systematically undermining the aggressor's war-economic potential. Ukrainian media amplified the dispute with the US comments, reporting the reactions of Germany's defence minister and Zelensky's framing of strikes on Wildberries and Ozon warehouses as a response to Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure serving drone and navigation component supply chains, and they framed the deep-strike question around whether Ukraine should be constrained, quoting the emphasis that Ukrainian combat potential should not be limited.

How international sources describe it

The coverage centres on a US official's public assessment of Ukrainian deep-strike tactics, framing it as a debate over whether strikes on civilian infrastructure in Russia aid or hinder ending the war. Reporting highlights allied divergence at Ramstein, with Germany and the UK publicly contesting the US criticism and pointing instead to Russian strikes on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure. US support priorities are presented as shifting European responsibility: continued PURL financing, European defence industrial capacity aimed at military needs, US congressional approval of the budget request for munitions and drone production, and continued US support for high-technology arms purchases under JUMPSTART. The framing notes Russia's continued mobilisation of manpower and economy, with the conflict expected to persist and US commitment to ending the war on terms of a lasting peace. Analytical assessments are included, such as ISW's reading of Russia's winter 2026–2027 strike campaign against Ukraine's energy security, and reporting on Ukrainian refinery strikes reducing Russian refining capacity by roughly 30% with fuel shortages in several regions.

Where reporting differs

Colby judged Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian civilian infrastructure, including Wildberries sites, ineffective for ending the war and for slowing Russian advance, and said such strikes likely hardened Russian public resolve and Kremlin readiness to escalate. Germany's Boris Pistorius called that criticism of strikes on Russian military targets 'unreasonable' and said the criticism should instead be directed at Russian terrorist strikes on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure, while the UK's Wes Streeting said the strikes helped weaken Russia's war machine, bought time and saved lives. Separately, Colby suggested the balance of advantage in long-range strikes could be entirely on Moscow's side, while his own assessment acknowledged strikes on Russian military-industrial targets can slow Russian advance, and he stressed his warnings do not mean Ukraine should be made to fight with its hands tied.

Background

The statements were made on 17 November at the opening of the 37th Ramstein Contact Group session at NATO headquarters in Brussels. Ukrainian strikes on Wildberries warehouses across multiple Russian regions began in mid-July and later extended to the logistics company Ozon; President Zelensky framed them as a response to Russian strikes on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure, noting the targeted sites supplied sanctioned components for drones and navigation equipment. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said the same day that Ukraine must defend itself, including by striking Russian logistics hubs, commenting on the Kerch bridge strike. Ukrainian forces increasingly strike Russian launch and production sites for ballistic missile components as Ukrainian air defence stocks shrink. US media reported in August 2025 that the Pentagon blocked Ukrainian long-range strikes on Russian territory for months, and that Colby developed a review mechanism for Kyiv's requests to use US long-range weapons and European allies' arms.