Published · Updated

Kushner Says Russia Agreed to Consider Ukraine Security Guarantees Resembling NATO Article 5

Jared Kushner said in Berlin on November 19 that the United States had persuaded Russia to consider security guarantees for Ukraine based on a mechanism similar to NATO’s Article 5. Donald Trump is reportedly open to reviewing such guarantees, but they would need to serve US interests and form part of a broader security package. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Ukraine and the United States may not share the same understanding of what such guarantees would entail.

Key points

  • Kushner announced the claimed Russian agreement during a briefing in Berlin on November 19, 2026.
  • Trump is reportedly ready to consider NATO Article 5-style guarantees for Ukraine if they serve US interests.
  • Any US agreement would need approval from Congress and form part of a broader security package.
  • Kushner said Russia remains deeply skeptical of and distrustful of the proposed guarantees.
  • The proposed system would include incentives, monitoring, deterrence, and consequences for violations.
  • Zelenskyy said partners must establish clear rules for responding to a possible renewed Russian attack.
  • Russia reportedly agreed to participate in multilateral negotiations involving European countries.

Why it matters

The reported Russian agreement could open the way for formal security guarantees for Ukraine, but the proposal remains preliminary. Any US arrangement would have to serve American interests, receive congressional approval and form part of a wider security framework. The dispute over what Article 5-style guarantees mean for Ukraine and the United States could determine whether the initiative produces a credible and enforceable response to a possible renewed Russian attack.

What happened

Speaking in Berlin after a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing on November 19, Kushner said the United States had persuaded Russia to consider guarantees for Ukraine based on a mechanism resembling NATO’s Article 5. He said Trump was willing to examine such guarantees if they served US interests, were approved by Congress and formed part of a broader security package. Kushner acknowledged substantial Russian skepticism and distrust toward the concept, which he said should rely on incentives, mutual interests, compliance monitoring, deterrence and consequences for violations.

Kushner also said Russia had agreed to participate in multilateral negotiations involving European countries and that direct European-Russian dialogue on security needed to resume. He described NATO as a central pillar of any future settlement and said Ukraine and Europe should be involved in shaping an agreement. Zelenskyy, however, said the United States and Ukraine might not share the same understanding of the guarantees. He said partners must provide clear rules for reacting to a possible renewed Russian attack, rules that would be understandable to Ukrainians, businesses and foreign investors. Washington reportedly did not answer his question about whether American troops would participate in guaranteeing Ukraine’s security.

How Ukrainian sources describe it

Ukrainian reporting focuses on the gap between the proposed model and Kyiv’s understanding of it. Zelenskyy said guarantees modeled on Article 5 imply the presence of foreign troops and bases in Ukraine and that American military involvement remained unanswered. Ukrainian coverage also emphasizes the need for explicit rules of partner reaction, the continued preference for NATO membership as the strongest guarantee of security, and the lack of final agreements. The reported Russian agreement is presented as a potential breakthrough, but with a substantial caveat.

How international sources describe it

The available framing centers on negotiations among the United States, Russia and European countries rather than commentary from international media. The key international mechanism under discussion is a NATO-inspired collective-defense model, embedded in a broader package that includes European participation, deterrence, monitoring and enforceable consequences.

Where reporting differs

Kushner said the United States had persuaded Russia to accept or at least seriously consider the Article 5-style concept, while simultaneously acknowledging significant skepticism and distrust in Russia. There is also an unresolved gap between Kyiv and Washington: Zelenskyy understands such guarantees as including foreign troops and bases, but the US response did not clarify whether American military personnel would take part.

Background

NATO’s Article 5 treats an armed attack on one or more allies as an attack on all alliance members, although each state independently determines what assistance to provide. Kushner wants NATO to serve as a central pillar of a future settlement and says a guarantee system should include incentives, monitoring, deterrence, consequences for violations and communication channels. Zelenskyy has described NATO membership as the best guarantee of security for Ukraine and Europe, while also identifying EU membership as a security guarantee.