Macron says Ukraine's NATO membership must be raised again
French President Emmanuel Macron said it was time to reconsider Ukraine's NATO membership, arguing that it would strengthen long-term European security. Speaking after a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, he said Russia had taken no concrete steps toward peace and stressed the importance of security guarantees for negotiations and a lasting settlement.
Key points
- Macron said Ukraine's NATO membership question should be raised again on November 19.
- He said the issue was postponed in the first half of 2022 because circumstances were different.
- The security-guarantees framework was finalized in January 2026 with US representatives.
- The plan provides continued support for Ukraine's army and its future force format.
- Coalition of the Willing forces could deploy in Ukraine after a peace is established, away from the front line.
- Zelensky said NATO membership would be the best security guarantee for Ukraine and Europe.
- Macron said Russia had not demonstrated any concrete steps toward peace.
Why it matters
Macron's call could revive NATO membership as a central element of European security policy. The existing guarantees include sustained support for Ukraine's military and a possible post-peace deployment of Coalition of the Willing forces. Macron and Zelensky both said strong guarantees are essential to negotiations and a durable peace.
What happened
Macron said the time had come to raise the question of Ukraine's NATO membership again during a press conference following a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin. He said the issue had been deferred in the first half of 2022 because circumstances were different, but Ukraine's membership would now support long-term European security. He also said the content of Ukraine's security guarantees had been finalized in January 2026 with US representatives. The framework provides support for the Ukrainian army in the coming years, helps determine its future format, and allows for a second support echelon. After peace is established, forces from Coalition of the Willing countries could be deployed on Ukrainian territory away from the front line. Macron said the guarantees remain in force and described them as providing Europe's security. He added that Russia had not demonstrated concrete steps toward peace and that the coming weeks would be critical.
How Ukrainian sources describe it
Ukrainian coverage emphasizes Zelensky's statement that NATO membership would be the strongest security guarantee for Ukraine and Europe. Ukrainian reports also identify NATO and the European Union as foundations of Europe's security architecture, alongside long-term military support and the possible presence of Coalition of the Willing forces after peace.
How international sources describe it
The international framing focuses on Macron's call to reconsider Ukraine's NATO membership within a broader European security strategy. It also highlights the agreed guarantees, European responsibility for security, the role of the United States and the planned format for peace negotiations involving Ukraine, Russia, the US and Europe.
Background
Ukraine's NATO membership question was postponed in the first half of 2022, when circumstances were different. The security-guarantees plan was finalized in January 2026 with US participation, while ongoing Koalicja training exercises in Poland were cited as evidence of the coalition's readiness. On November 14, Zelensky said US negotiators had raised the possibility of withdrawing Ukrainian forces from the Kyiv-controlled part of Donbas in exchange for NATO membership. Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda said he did not expect progress in Ukraine's peace negotiations before spring 2027 and believed Russia wanted the war to continue through another difficult winter.