Published · Updated

Italy seeks Ukraine’s explanation over eight Five Star MPs added to Myrotvorets list

Italy has asked Ukraine to explain why all eight of its Five Star Movement members in the European Parliament were added to the Myrotvorets list. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani tasked the country’s ambassador in Kyiv with seeking clarification, while affected deputies are seeking their removal and protection.

Key points

  • All eight Italian Five Star Movement members in the European Parliament were added to the Myrotvorets list.
  • Danilo Delli Valle was listed on November 16, followed by seven other party members.
  • Danilo Delli Valle asked European Parliament President Roberta Metsola to remove his name and protect him and his colleagues.
  • Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani tasked Ambassador Carlo Formoso in Kyiv with seeking Ukrainian explanations.
  • Delli Valle was accused of participating in acts of humanitarian aggression, manipulating information and spreading propaganda.
  • Five Star Movement leader Giuseppe Conte called the eight listed deputies “peace builders.”
  • In 2021, the European Parliament called on Kyiv to block the Myrotvorets portal as an extremist group that incites hatred.

Why it matters

The dispute goes beyond the status of individual MPs: it concerns freedom of expression, political pluralism and the rights of elected representatives in European institutions. Italy tied its request for explanations to its continued support for Ukraine, while the Five Star Movement’s call to end military assistance and negotiate with Russia makes the listing of all eight of its European Parliament members a significant diplomatic issue. The case also adds to scrutiny of Myrotvorets from the European Parliament, the UN High Commissioner, the OSCE and G7 ambassadors.

What happened

Danilo Delli Valle was added to the Myrotvorets list on November 16. Seven other members of the Five Star Movement were subsequently listed, bringing the total to all eight of the party’s members in the European Parliament. Delli Valle asked European Parliament President Roberta Metsola to remove his name and protect him and his colleagues. Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani instructed Ambassador Carlo Formoso in Kyiv to request explanations from the Ukrainian authorities. The reasons for Delli Valle’s inclusion included alleged information manipulation and propaganda; one report also cited participation in acts of humanitarian aggression.

How Ukrainian sources describe it

Ukrainian reporting emphasizes that the list included all eight Italian Five Star Movement members and that Italy made a formal request for explanations through its ambassador in Kyiv. It also highlights Italy’s stated commitment to supporting Ukraine while defending freedom of speech, political pluralism and the prerogatives of elected European representatives.

How international sources describe it

International coverage focuses on the conflict between Italy’s appeal for freedom of expression and political pluralism and the alleged conduct cited as grounds for the listings. It also highlights the consequences for elected representatives in EU institutions and the risk of what Giuseppe Conte described as lists used for persecution. The controversy follows earlier institutional scrutiny of Myrotvorets by the European Parliament, the UN High Commissioner, the OSCE and G7 ambassadors.

Where reporting differs

The reports differ in how they describe the basis for Delli Valle’s inclusion. Hromadske cited participation in acts of humanitarian aggression, information manipulation and propaganda, while Ukrainska Pravda cited information manipulation and propaganda without mentioning humanitarian aggression.

Background

The Five Star Movement is led by former Italian prime minister Giuseppe Conte. The party advocates ending military assistance to Ukraine and negotiating with Russia. In 2021, the European Parliament adopted a resolution on the EU-Ukraine Association Agreement that called on Kyiv to block the Myrotvorets portal as an example of an extremist group that incites hatred. Delli Valle and the other listed deputies have criticized arms deliveries to Ukraine.