Kiel Institute: only about €41.7 billion of Germany's €100 billion in declared Ukraine aid actually reached Ukraine
An analysis by the Kiel Institute for the World Economy's Ukraine Support Tracker finds that of the €100 billion the German government counts as bilateral support to Ukraine, only about €41.7 billion actually went to Ukraine. Around 80% of declared civilian aid was spent inside Germany, much of it on social payments to Ukrainian refugees. The study comes as Berlin announces fresh aid packages and transfers of Patriot interceptors.
Key points
- Kiel Institute estimates only about €41.7 billion of Germany's declared €100 billion in bilateral aid reached Ukraine
- Some 80% of declared civilian aid (€35.9 billion) was spent in Germany, including €27.45 billion on social payments to Ukrainian refugees
- Only €7.4 billion of German civilian aid went directly to Ukraine
- In 2022–2025 Germany allocated about €22.7 billion in military aid, with €11.6 billion more for 2026 and €22 billion in future obligations
- The Kiel Institute traced €56.3 billion in military support — €1.3 billion less than the federal government's figure
- Since June 2025 Germany has stopped publishing detailed military aid breakdowns
- On 4 October Chancellor Merz announced a new aid package worth over €1.3 billion, including weapons deliveries and energy support
Why it matters
The analysis reframes a politically resonant €100 billion figure by separating what actually reached Ukraine from refugee-related spending inside Germany. It exposes a transparency gap, since Germany has stopped publishing detailed military aid line items since June 2025, and flags a €1.3 billion discrepancy between the government's military total and what independent researchers can verify. The finding matters because Germany is the largest European bilateral donor to Ukraine, and the methodology of measuring that support shapes political debate about burden-sharing and about how much military and economic help Ukraine is realistically receiving.
What happened
The Kiel Institute for the World Economy published a study under its Ukraine Support Tracker examining Germany's bilateral support to Ukraine. Its central finding is that of the €100 billion the German government counted as bilateral aid to Ukraine as of 30 June 2026, only about €41.7 billion actually reached Ukraine. Of the €43.3 billion classified as civilian support, around €35.9 billion (roughly 80%) was spent in Germany: €27.45 billion went to social payments, known in Germany as Bürgergeld, for Ukrainian refugees; €7.15 billion was transferred by the federal government to Germany's federal states and municipalities for housing and supporting refugees; and €1.3 billion consisted of export and investment guarantees for German companies operating in Ukraine. Only about €7.4 billion of civilian aid reached Ukraine directly, including €6.3 billion in humanitarian aid, emergency energy support and reconstruction of Ukrainian state institutions, €1 billion as a grant to an IMF-administered account for the Ukrainian state, and €0.1 billion in debt relief. The Kiel Institute was able to confirm €56.3 billion in military support, about €1.3 billion less than the €57.6 billion figure cited by the German government; the federal government has not provided sufficient information to explain the gap. Christoph Trebesch, who heads the Ukraine Support Tracker, said the €100 billion figure is misleading when labeled as bilateral aid to Ukraine, while noting that Germany remains the largest European donor to Ukraine. The analysis comes against a backdrop of new announcements from Berlin: on 8 September Defence Minister Boris Pistorius said Germany would transfer PAC-2 interceptors for Patriot air-defense systems from Bundeswehr stocks to Ukraine before winter; on 4 October Chancellor Friedrich Merz announced during a visit to Kyiv a new aid package worth over €1.3 billion, including more than €1 billion in military support — covering joint production of interceptor drones against Shaheds — and roughly €350 million for energy-system repairs before winter.
How Ukrainian sources describe it
The available reporting comes from Ukrainian outlets that frame the Kiel Institute study as evidence that Berlin's headline figure overstates what Ukraine actually receives, with Trebesch's characterisation of the €100 billion as misleading featured prominently. The same coverage pairs the audit with reporting on Chancellor Merz's 4 October visit to Kyiv and his announcement of a new €1.3 billion aid package, and quotes President Volodymyr Zelensky on the signing of 15 agreements and documents worth more than €8.5 billion on the same day, presenting concrete new commitments alongside the critical reading of past totals.
Where reporting differs
The German government's August assessment values total support to Ukraine at €100 billion — €43.3 billion civilian and €57.6 billion military, counting refugee-related spending inside Germany as part of that total. The Kiel Institute's Ukraine Support Tracker estimates only about €41.7 billion of that figure qualifies as bilateral aid that actually reached Ukraine, and traces €56.3 billion in military aid, €1.3 billion less than the government's number. Christoph Trebesch says the €100 billion figure is misleading when described as bilateral aid to Ukraine; the German government, in turn, defends counting refugee-related domestic spending as part of its Ukraine support.
Background
The Kiel Institute for the World Economy runs the Ukraine Support Tracker, an independent accounting of international aid to Ukraine. Germany frames its support as both civilian and military, with the civilian category including social spending on Ukrainian refugees inside Germany. Germany and Ukraine agreed a strategic partnership in April 2026 covering joint arms production, air defense, drones and long-range systems. Since June 2025 the German government has continued to publish overall aid totals but has stopped publishing detailed military aid line items. The Kiel Institute study was triggered by the German government's August assessment of its support to Ukraine as of 30 June 2026 at €100 billion.