Published · Updated

Hungary to keep granting EU temporary protection to Ukrainian conscription-age men, citing Article 7 discretion

Hungary has formally notified the European Commission that it will not apply the EU Temporary Protection Directive's provision barring protection for Ukrainians with unfulfilled military obligations, and will continue granting temporary protection to conscription-age Ukrainian men, primarily from Transcarpathia. European Commission spokesperson Markus Lammert said Hungary is exercising the discretion provided by Article 7 of the directive, and that the move will carry no EU-level consequences. The European Commission declined to assess whether Hungary's emphasis on Transcarpathia amounts to selective treatment of ethnic Hungarians.

Key points

  • Hungary notified the European Commission it will not implement the Temporary Protection Directive's bar on protection for Ukrainians with unfulfilled military obligations.
  • European Commission spokesperson Markus Lammert said Hungary is using the discretion provided by Article 7 of the directive.
  • Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar said on 3 September that Hungary will continue protecting conscription-age Ukrainian men, primarily from Transcarpathia (Zakarpattia).
  • Lammert said member states cannot narrow the categories entitled to protection but can extend it to additional ones under Article 7.
  • An EU official said Hungary's decision will not trigger consequences from the EU side.
  • The EU Council decided in July to extend temporary protection for Ukrainians until 4 March 2028, with the rule against protecting men unauthorised to leave for military reasons taking effect from 5 August.
  • EU Commissioner for Home Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner said the request to exclude conscription-age men came from Ukraine itself.

Why it matters

Hungary's move creates a direct divergence from the rest of the EU on a politically sensitive aspect of the war — the treatment of military-age Ukrainian men fleeing conscription — and specifically singles out Transcarpathia, where many ethnic Hungarians live, raising questions about whether protection is being applied selectively. The European Commission's confirmation that the step is permitted under Article 7 and will bring no EU-level consequences highlights the member-state discretion built into the Temporary Protection Directive framework.

What happened

Hungary formally told the European Commission that it will not apply the part of the EU Temporary Protection Directive that bars protection for Ukrainians with unfulfilled military obligations, and will instead continue granting temporary protection to conscription-age Ukrainian men, primarily from Transcarpathia. Commission spokesperson Markus Lammert said Hungary was using the discretion that Article 7 of the directive gives member states to extend protection to additional categories of displaced persons. He added that, under the rules, member states cannot narrow the circle of people entitled to protection but can broaden it, and that Hungary's decision would not trigger consequences from the EU side. Lammert declined to assess whether Hungary's focus on Transcarpathia amounts to selective treatment of ethnic Hungarians and suggested questions on the Hungarian government's intentions be put to Budapest. The notification follows a statement by Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar on 3 September that Hungary would keep protecting conscription-age Ukrainian men from the region.

Background

In July 2025, the EU Council extended temporary protection for Ukrainians fleeing the war until 4 March 2028 and agreed that, in principle, temporary protection should not be granted to people who recently arrived without authorisation from Ukraine to leave due to military obligations. From 5 August, newly arrived Ukrainians have been required to confirm lawful departure and document fulfilment of or exemption from military obligations to receive temporary protection; the change does not apply retroactively to those already holding temporary protection. EU Commissioner for Home Affairs and Migration Magnus Brunner said the request to exclude conscription-age men came from Ukraine itself. Article 7 of the Temporary Protection Directive allows member states to extend protection to additional categories of displaced persons, but not to narrow the categories entitled to it. Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar said on 3 September that Hungary would continue to protect conscription-age Ukrainian men, primarily from Transcarpathia.