Published · Updated

Ukraine weighs new prosecutor general selection law as EU ties funding to reform

Ukraine is discussing a separate law on selecting the prosecutor general and possible changes to the appointment procedure. The EU says the current prosecution-reform bill is sufficient for related funding, but a positive IBAR assessment requires a more transparent, merit-based selection process. A task force will continue evaluating options after the year ends, while constitutional constraints and disagreements over holding a contest remain unresolved.

Key points

  • Ukraine needs a separate law on selecting the prosecutor general.
  • A positive IBAR assessment requires reforms to the prosecutor general appointment procedure.
  • The proposed procedure must be more transparent and based on merit.
  • An interagency task force will continue reviewing options in the new year.
  • The EU supports the current prosecution-reform bill as sufficient for related funding.
  • Current practice requires 226 parliamentary votes; otherwise, the candidate serves as acting prosecutor general.

Why it matters

A more transparent and merit-based selection procedure is a condition for a positive IBAR assessment. A separate selection law could strengthen institutional safeguards and affect EU funding linked to judicial reform. The discussions also intersect with constitutional limits, presidential powers, the need for parliamentary approval and possible international involvement in selecting the prosecutor general.

What happened

An interagency task force is examining options for changing the procedure for appointing Ukraine's prosecutor general. Its objective is to find a solution that meets the benchmarks and follows both the spirit and the letter of IBAR. The work will continue in the new year because the deadline for completing this task has not yet arrived. Options under consideration include an open competition involving an independent commission that may include international experts, or bringing in a third party such as the Ethics Council or EU representatives.

At present, the president selects a candidate and submits the nomination to the Verkhovna Rada, Ukraine's parliament, for approval. After the vote, the president signs the appointment decree. If a candidate fails to secure the required 226 votes, the candidate takes office as acting prosecutor general. The task force is also taking into account the Constitution's provisions concerning the prosecutor general and the president's powers. Ukraine is expected to prepare a separate law on the selection procedure.

How Ukrainian sources describe it

Ukrainian coverage centers on the need for a separate selection law, the work of the task force and a parliamentary bill submitted in June. It also contrasts official support for the current prosecution-reform bill with the need for separate changes to the prosecutor general appointment procedure, while highlighting disagreement over whether a competition should be held.

How international sources describe it

The EU's position is the principal external benchmark in the available coverage. It supports the existing prosecution-reform bill and considers its text good and sufficient for related funding, but says changes to the prosecutor general selection procedure are necessary for a positive IBAR assessment. International participation appears only as a possible feature of alternative selection models.

Where reporting differs

ZN.UA and Ukrainian Pravda report opposite positions attributed to Deputy Prime Minister for European and Euro-Atlantic Integration Всеволод Ченцов: one says a competition for prosecutor general is unnecessary, while the other says it is necessary.

Background

Under the current procedure, the president nominates the prosecutor general, submits the candidate to the Verkhovna Rada for a vote and issues the appointment decree after approval. Without the required 226 votes, the candidate serves as acting prosecutor general. In June, Anastasia Radina, chair of the parliamentary committee on anti-corruption policy, said a bill on competitive selection for prosecutor general had been submitted to the Verkhovna Rada.